Saturday, 12 December 2015

Trying to avoid generating new misconceptions


It is amazing how you can generate misconceptions, especially, as in my case, when you don't fully explain what you mean. 

Manmade chemical fertilisers do not necessarily degrade soil.  However they replace essential organic matter in the form of composts and manures which are essential for maintaining soil life and structure. 
I remember seeing a farmer on the television complaining that when he tried to plough in his straw stubble rather than burn it,  it had not decomposed even after one year. 
He held some of his soil in his hand to demonstrate that the straw was still there.  From what I saw the soil was no more than dust with little organic matter and virtually no life within it.  He had been using man made chemical fertilisers for years.  No wonder the straw did not decompose.

We have been throwing away vast amounts of local organic matter - the leaves swept up in towns and cities, shredded woody material, our vegetable peelings, our garden waste- that could easily be composted and used as fertiliser.  Although we are starting to utilise this material now rather than burning or adding it to land fill sites,  an awful amount is still wasted. 
Many years ago I wrote about how nutrients from far off lands were being imported to this country in the form of food plants like citrus fruit, tea and coffee.  We ate them and then flushed them into the sea through the sewers.  If we left the nutrients in the countries that need them allowing them to produce enough food for themselves rather than export it to us then there may be a little less starvation in the world.  Also, we need to consider whether we can rejoin the natural recycling of humanure rather than just flushing it into the sea and contributing to dead zones. 

Man made fertilisers do not necessarily degrade the soil, however they are expensive, based on oil technology, use vast amounts of energy, have to be transported large distances and bypass the necessity of adding organic matter to the soil. 
Although we can grow plants by hydroponics in sterile factories, I still would rather grow and eat a moth eaten organically home grown vegetable.  Not because it tastes better or because it has more vitamins or it has more fibre or because it doesn’t need to be transported vast distances or it’s  not covered in unwanted pesticides or because it is not overfull of nitrogen produced by the Haber Bosh process but just because it is a wonderful thing to be able to do.  Fresh is best.

Internal Consistency in Gardening

It is not consistent to attempt to dispel myths by producing more yourself. 

One of the most powerful concepts of science is internal consistency.  The laws of science operate in whichever science is being studied and consistency must be maintained within a science. 

So how does this apply to my gardening? 

Dowding suggests in his book "Gardening Myths" that digging is not necessary in a vegetable garden.  He is making the same assertion as Bill Mollison did in his book, "Permaculture: A Designers Manuel" written in 1988.  I'll go along with this.  I will avoid digging, however I reserve the right  to dig when I feel it is necessary. 

They both say that digging causes damage and death to soil inhabitants such as worms, beetles, bacteria and in particular mychorrhizal fungi and it also causes a loss of existing soil structure. 

Now to be internally consistent this should apply whenever digging is used. 

I have been turning over the compost in my compost bins today.  I try to turn the compost every two days as Geoff Lawton suggested in the Permaculture course I have just completed.  While the compost is being turned, I shake it out well with a fork.  After about ten days the constituents of the compost start to fall apart and turning becomes progressively easier. 

The compost is full of wildlife especially various types of worms.  However, there are also lots of beetles, slugs, snails, millipedes, centipedes and woodlice.  All of which are helping with the process of decomposition. 

As we have decomposition, there must be both bacteria and fungi mixed in with the compost.  Indeed fungi mycelium can be seen particularly in the woody material and tree leaves. 

So, if digging damages organisms in the soil, why  doesn't it damage them in the compost when it is turned over? 

Dowding says that there is a loss of organic matter from the soil as carbon dioxide if it is dug.  This is consistent with the reduction in volume of the compost as it rots down.  But, how is the carbon dioxide produced in the dug soil if there are no bacteria and fungi decomposing the organic matter? 

Bacteria and fungi use the carbon in organic matter to produce their mass and energy.  The final product of both these processes is carbon dioxide and water.  (For the scientists: catabolism when they are alive and anabolism when they die.)

Carbon dioxide is not produced by magic.  There is a biochemical process that can be described to explain its appearance and this involves the presence of bacteria and fungi. 

I would really suggest that bacteria and fungi are not killed off and digging does not sterilise the soil.  I wish it would because it would be an easy way of getting rid of club root and white rot fungi. 

So if club root and white rot are not killed in the soil by digging is mychorrhizal fungi?  I doubt it, but I still like to add mychorrhizal fungi spores when planting out fruit and vegetables.  The more spores there are near the roots the more likely they are going to be infected by mychorrhizal fungi. 

The same people that are telling me mychorrhizal fungi are killed due to digging then tell me it is not worth adding mychorrhizal spores because they are ubiquitous in the soil.  This is not consistent. 

There is some well documented data that suggests that there are less worms in cultivated soil than in  lawns and pastures.  However, beware of correlation.  Is the cause of this cultivation or are we just seeing a habitat preference?  Identifying cause and effect is not always that easy. 

There is no doubt that some worms are killed during digging.  The silly myth that one half of a worm will regenerate if it is sliced in two is false.  What you get is two dead halves.  There is also evidence that worms do not like disturbance so avoiding digging whenever possible is probably a good strategy if you want to encourage worms into your garden. 

Lets see if there is internal consistency with soil structure.

I would say that it takes about three to four weeks of turning every two days to make some good friable, well structured, open compost that looks very like good soil.  So if turning the compost does not destroy structure but, on the contrary, improves it greatly, why does digging destroy structure in soil?  I don't think it does.  It is the loss of organic matter that causes collapse of soil structure. 

There are many good reasons for not digging the soil but I don't think that killing soil organisms and destroying soil structure are two of them. 

Thursday, 10 December 2015

Yet more myths and legends: misconceptions in gardening.

Really I shouldn't get upset when people like Dowding say they feed plants.  Indeed the definition of food is not all that clear even in science.  However, it does lead to some interesting misconceptions. 

Plants use the energy from sunlight to convert carbon dioxide and water into molecules that can provide them with energy and mass.  They make their own food.  The process is called photosynthesis and plants are referred to as photo autotrophs.  They also need relatively tiny amounts of elements like nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium.  They combine these elements with the molecules formed from carbon dioxide and water to make all the compounds they need to survive. 

Animals can't do this so they eat the chemicals that plants make.  They are called heterotrophs.  (They can also get these chemicals from other animals that have eaten plants.) These chemicals are usually called food. 

Fungi can't photosynthesise and need to get their energy and mass from chemicals produced by plants.  They are heterotrophs too.  Bacteria get their energy and mass from a number of different sources.  They can be heterotrophs, however some  are autotrophs.  Some can utilise energy from the Sun and others can utilise energy from chemicals.  These include the decomposers. 

Why is this important for gardeners?  Well understanding this means that you can appreciate what is happening when you add fertilisers and manures and it will help you to understand what is happening when you are making compost.

 So you can't feed plants in the same way as you can feed animals and fungi. 

You can supply chemicals that contain nutrients like phosphorus, nitrogen and potassium to the soil where they can break down into soluble salts which can be taken up by the roots of plants.  However, I find it difficult to describe this as, "feeding plants." 

Also there is a limit to the amount of these nutrients needed by plants and their rate of uptake.  Plants will need them when and where they are actively growing. 

Adding chemical fertilisers bypasses the normal pathways of decay and decomposition.  These soluble salts dissolve relatively quickly and  are readily taken up by plants to enhance growth.  However, this is not really sustainable because it relies a great deal on fossil fuels to generate these fertilisers.  Also it leads to soil degeneration.  Chemicals that stick soil particles together like humus are lost and organisms, like worms, fungi and bacteria that produce sticky mucilage do not have food to survive.  Soil structure begins to break down and eventually yields are considerably reduced.  Less water can be stored in the soil and it becomes very dusty and easily eroded by both wind and rain. 

Nutrients are stored in the soil by being attached to clay and organic material.  Both clay and organic material are light and easily removed by wind and water leaving the heavier sand and stone which store much less nutrient and water.  This we call soil degradation.

Compost and manure in bays made from pallets
Providing nutrients appropriately is achieved much more efficiently by adding organic material such as compost or manure.  Composts and manures add much more than nutrients to the soil.  They add material in different states of decomposition and a community of decomposer organisms and their predators.  Composts and manures also add soil particle binding chemicals that improve the soil structure, increase air and water filled porosity, reduce bulk density and produce a very friable soil. 

Manure and woody chippings are both valuable organic matter.
Some people suggest that there is a limit to the amount of organic matter that can be added to the soil.  If there is then I have not found it yet.  I am adding copious amounts of compost, manure and woody chippings throughout the year and there does not seem to be any depletion of yield. 

Both fungi and bacteria excrete enzymes that can be stabilized by clay and organic material and continue to break down composts and manure to produce plant nutrients.   Decomposers produce mucilage which is sticky and binds the soil particles together and prevents them from being blown away by the wind. 

Compost bins make good compost if you turn the compost regularly but they rarely heat up
very much.
It is true that there is much less nutrient in composts and manures than there is in the same volume of inorganic fertilisers.    However, plants need a tiny amount of these nutrient compared to that of carbon dioxide and water.  We are doing well providing plants with carbon dioxide from ancient carbon when we burn oil.  So really the limiting factor is water. 

Composts, manures and other organic matter also help to retain water in the soil.  They are sponges that soak up excess water and release it slowly to make it available to plants.  A covering mulch of organic material will reduce surface evaporation considerably.  It will also help to prevent wind and rain erosion. 

Really, in the UK we should not have to water plants outside, however if we do water then we should give the water when the plants are actively photosynthesising.  That's when they need it.  This will be when it is light and the best time to give it is in the morning so that it will be available to use during the daylight time of the day.  (A day is 24 hours.) 

It is true that anything that was once alive will decompose and form a good compost.  Wood rots very easily if it gets wet.  I put up to 15cm long and  5cm diameter cut branches in the compost.  First they change colour to a very dark brown.  Then they go very brittle and can be easily broken.  Then they become very friable and can be pulled apart by hand.  That's why I don't like to use wooden edging for the vegetable beds. 

As Dowding says, perennial weeds such as couch grass make very good compost. And I agree with him. They look very unpromising in the photographs below but they change colour to a very dark brown after a week and start to break apart after about ten days. Bits of plastic, metal, glass and stone fall out of it, and by three weeks you cannot tell what the compost has been made from.  At one month it is good enough to sieve and put onto the vegetable beds.  Although this looks very woody, there are still  nutrients locked up in it. 

Mixture of stinging nettle, couch grass and mare's tail being composted. I dried it very well
before composing it.

I added comfrey liquid and turned it every two days to produce a very good compost. I'm doing
the same with the perennial weeds we got off the new car park.
Cotton and wool (good sources of nitrogen) in the form of sweaters, jumpers, trousers and shirts all rot down.  In Victorian times farmers used a lot of rags as a fertiliser but they did not want them washed! 

Leather shoes, belts and bags decompose very slowly.  The gardeners at the Alternative Technology Centre in Wales told me that old horse saddles and tackle rots down particularly slowly. 

Cardboard rots down remarkably quickly and so too does paper shredded or not. 

When we had horse manure delivered free to the allotment site, some allotmenteers would separate out the horse hair, rejecting it and leaving it to one side.  Hair is about 90% keratin.  Keratin is a protein and proteins contain nitrogen.  I collected the hair up, thanking those that sorted it out for me, and added it to my soil. 

Dowding says correctly that both citrus peel and rhubarb leaves can be added to the compost heap.  They both rot down very quickly.  Citrus peel contains a natural pesticide called d-limonene, however the pesticide can only be made from very concentrated citrus oil.  It is an insecticide and does not affect the decomposer worms, fungi and bacteria in the compost heap.  They will rot it down just like all the other organic chemicals in the heap.  Rhubarb leaves contain oxalic acid which might cause us a problem if we eat too much of it but does not present a problem for worms, fungi and bacteria.  Its just another source of carbon for them. 


Woody chippings used as mulch.  They decompose slowly over a year and there is no
noticeable nitrogen immobilisation. 
The growing points and small leaves at the tips of stems are where most nutrients obtained from the soil are being used.   This is where the plants will use most energy and resources to grow.   

Where does most of the energy and resources come from?   

Well from leaves that are no longer growing.  The large moth eaten leaves near the base of the plant.  These are the photosynthesising powerhouses that fuel growth in the rest of the plant. 

Yet these are the leaves some people remove from their tomato plants. 

Leave your tomato leaves alone. You will get a lot more tomato fruit. 

Saturday, 5 December 2015

More myths and legends: misconceptions in gardening

I have seen people take off weeds together with top soil, bag it up and take it to the local municipal waste disposal site.  They dig but do not add anything to the soil and plant and sow into what I would imagine is very unpromising soil.  However, they seem to get a really good crop of vegetables.  And this continues over several years. 

I don't know how they do this unless they surreptitiously creep in and spread artificial fertiliser around.  It may, however, suggest that soil is more resilient than we imagine and can deal with human interference better than we expect. 

Reason would suggest that you have to replace what you take from the soil.  However, plants take very small amounts of nutrient from the soil.  A great deal of which is replaced by the weathering of rock and stone already in the soil. 

Also, plants don't want to die.  They don't die just to spite us.  They will make great efforts and struggle to survive wherever they grow. 

This is why I take little credit for the vegetables that grow on my allotment.  They do all the growing; I just try to make it as easy for them as possible. 

So what is my point?  There are some pretty amazing misconceptions out there but most of them are harmless and amusing.  Plants grow regardless.

Does it really matter if we put egg shells on our compost? 

I don't think so. 

Whether they decompose or just fall apart because of weathering does not really impinge on my gardening at all.

However Dowding doesn't  seem to understand the role of nitrogen fixing bacteria in legume root nodules. A slightly more important misconception, that does affect my gardening.  He quotes Chris Beardshaw on "Gardeners' Question Time." when he says that most of the nitrogen fixed by bacteria in the root nodules passes to the stems, leaves and fruit.  I doubt very much whether just 3% of the original fix of nitrogen remains in the roots because I have read that up to 40% does.  However, I'll go with the 3% because it is not relevant. 

Dowding says that to get an increase in soil nitrogen you have to dig in the stems when they are in full leaf.  Well yes.  Even though I was keeping a lot of fruit for seed, I still dug in the beans when they were in full leaf.  They were in full leaf until almost the end of November.  Even when they are caught by the frost, the leaves and stems and consequently the nitrogen are still there and can be dug in blackened.  I don't see the problem.  Nitrogen does not flaunt the law of conservation of matter.  It does not disappear.  If all the leaves fall from the stems onto the soil surface they will add their nitrogen to the soil eventually.  Even if you leave the plants till the end of the winter and they are brown and crinkly, they will still contain some fixed nitrogen and can contribute to adding extra nitrogen to the soil. 

The problem for others is that the root or the root nodules are seen as the only source of nitrogen that beans plants contribute.  I hope to explain why this is a misconception. 

I questioned this on one website and they said that they were trying to simplify nitrogen fixation for general gardeners.  If we are going to try to overcome misconceptions then we have to tell people exactly what is happening based on evidence and data.  And anyway who decides whether something is difficult or easy?  Is there a scale of difficultness. If so what are the units?


All these bean plants have been dug into the
soil to add a small amount of fixed nitrogen.
-everything helps
I have also seen the misconception that all of the nitrogen produced by nitrogen fixing bacteria passes into the seeds of legumes.  This would wrongly suggest that digging in the roots and stems of say runner beans would not necessarily introduce nitrogen into the soil. 

It is true that a lot of nitrogen passes into bean seeds (and this is where vegetarians get some of  their protein from.)  Indeed all plants pass nitrogen, as part of protein, into their seeds.  (That's why vegetarians eat lots of nuts. ) 

Why am I talking about proteins rather than nitrogen?  The element nitrogen is incorporated as part of protein molecules almost immediately it has been fixed by nodule bacteria like Rhizobium leguminosarum  or Rhizobium gallicum and passes into the plant.  These proteins are then used throughout the plant for a vast number of different jobs.  So to say that all or even most fixed nitrogen is passed to the seeds or stays in the root nodules seems hard to believe.  Even if only a small amount of nitrogen is left as protein in the main structure of the plant, you are still getting an increase of nitrogen that can be incorporated into the soil if you dig in the bean plants at the end of the season. 

If you cut the tops off beans and burn them then the nitrogen will be lost to the atmosphere as nitrogen oxide gases.  At the very least the tops of beans and peas should be composted for their fixed nitrogen. 

However, why not just dig the whole plant in? 

Tall climbing pea plants have been dug into the
soil to add nitrogen.
Some books say just dig in the roots.  The roots contain Rhizobium filled nodules.  The usefulness of nitrogen, as a basic building block of proteins, would mean that it would be transported away from the nodules as quickly as possible.  Thus there would be no more nitrogen in the nodules than there would be in the rest of the plant.  The increase in fixed nitrogen is distributed as protein throughout the plant.  The farmer does not mow off the leaves of clover and just plough in the roots.

Everything helps, so dig in the whole legume plant.  Why wouldn't you?  Maybe because the stems are a little woody and this might lead to nitrogen immobilisation?  Possibly, but the jury is definitely out about how much woody chippings cause immobilisation so a few bean tops, which in my anecdotal experience rot down relatively quickly, are not going to cause a problem.  Also  legume green manures, such as vetch, tare, fenugreek and field bean, are dug into the soil, tops and all. So why not beans and peas? 


Green manure of tares, clover and rye grass

Once the legume plant dies, the Rhizobium bacteria pass back into the soil where they can survive but do not fix nitrogen.  The nitrogen contribution that  bean roots make comes from decomposition of the proteins that make them up. 


Sweet peas were used as a break crop and
 dug in as a legume nitrogen fixer.

There are other free living nitrogen fixing bacteria but they are not thought to make a very significant contribution to total soil nitrogen.

A misconception I had was that legumes could only introduce nitrogen into the soil when they were dug in.  However, as with other plants, the turnover of their roots is quite significant.  They are loosing material from their root tips continually and root hairs only have a very short life.  This is why lawns with clover growing in them look much healthier and a darker green than those that don't. Indeed, Abercrombe suggests that during the eighteenth century the lawns of the super rich Victorians were sown with a grass clover mix. 

The nitrogen is coming from the death and decomposition of proteins in roots, root exudates and sheared off cells.  Not necessarily from root nodules which only contain bacteria.  The only way that root nodules would contribute to soil nitrogen is if they were seared off or died and the protein within them decomposed.  They are not little bags of nitrogen as Dowding seems to suggest. 

Dowding's objection to green manures really stems from the fact that most gardeners will dig them in and he doesn't like digging.  Well actually you don't necessarily need to dig them in or compost the tops as he suggests.  If you lay cardboard and chippings over them,  maybe tarpaulins or black plastic or even as a last resort carpets, green manure will decompose under the soil covers but above the soil.  The soil does not have to be disturbed and you get the benefits of the nitrogen fixation and added organic matter. 

So this is why I have planted legumes  Laburnum anagyroides and Lupinus x Russel Hybrids at the top of the allotment slope.  I am hoping that any fixed nitrogen that is produced by the decomposition of root proteins will be taken by mass flow of water through the allotment soil thus making it available for the vegetables down slope. 

Which takes us to another misconception: the danger of  Laburnum spp..  They are not that poisonous and are no more poisonous than sweet peas, cherry laurel, pyracantha, and even French beans ( Phaseolus vulgaris).    A hysteria about laburnum in the UK means that they have been rooted out of all UK school gardens.  Have a look at the Youtube film:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Jk1IsHkQs-k#t=0

I grow  laburnum, sweet pea and lupin on the allotment as nitrogen fixers.  I just don't eat them.

Thursday, 3 December 2015

Myths and Legends; Misconceptions in Gardening.

It's all a conspiracy - the world is flat.

I've just bought Charles Dowding's book; "Gardening Myth and misconceptions." published in 2014.  I have read its 91 pages fairly quickly and found it really interesting. 

He, like many other modern commentators, are following an long tradition of challenging gardening misconceptions. 

Ralph Austen's in his 1653 book; "A Treatise of Fruit Trees Showing the Manner of Grafting, Setting, Pruning and Ordering Them"  set out to expose myths during Oliver Cromwell's time. 

He rejected the idea: "To have all stone fruit taste as you shall think good, lay the stones to soak in such liquor as yea should have them taste of."  Together with: "To have red apples put grafts in pike's blood."

Both perfectly reasonable assertions.  (My choice would be Scotch whiskey.)

As are modern misconceptions - put science misconceptions into Utube and you will be very surprised about what ordinary people think about science "facts" that have relatively large amounts of evidence to suggest that they are more or less correct. 

Evolution is rejected even though it is the explanation of hybridisation (Fairchild's mule), plant breeding, plant cloning(taking cuttings), the origin of flowering plants, plant adaptations and interactions with pollinators, plant genetics and grafting.  (Why you can't graft a peach onto an apple. Has God done this just to be awkward?)

Lettuce, believe it or not, does contain protein!  All living things that we know about have proteins.  Proteins are fundamental to life on the Earth.  Don't ask me as a vegetarian where I get my protein from!  I get it from lettuce.   

Let's remember photosynthesis when considering where the mass of a tree comes from.  Yes, those  
Sequoiadendron giganteum are overwhelmingly  just wisps of carbon dioxide gas and drops of water and so are we.  The scraps of other nutrients that plants get from the soil are minisculely insignificant in comparison.  They do not get their mass from the soil.
"General Sherman tree looking up" by Jim Bahn - Sherman Tree
Uploaded by hike395.
 Licensed under CC BY 2.0 via Commons -
That's why General Sherman does not have a gigantic hole around it.  I  know cus I've been there.
I must admit to a vested interest in science misconceptions.  They were my area of research while I was teaching at University and my Master's degree was in the public understanding of science and science communication.  I was researching the misconceptions of children and found that my students - some of which were Masters graduates - seemed to have the same misunderstandings. 

One of the areas I interested in was people's understanding of the phases of the Moon.  This is how we see "daylight" and "night" on the Moon's surface from earth (the planets including the Earth have phases too!).  I have to be careful here because a day is defined as 24 hours on the Earth.   Many people still think that phases of the Moon are bought about by the shadow of the Earth and some children think you can sit on the crescent Moon fishing.  Dowding, although cautious,  seems to suggest a connection between how we see daylight and night on the Moon and the most auspicious time to plant seeds.

Most scientists would say that correlation does not mean cause and effect.  Something that social scientists really need to take on board.  Particularly those in education research.  If its not significant - then it is not significant.  A great deal of evidence is needed to establish  relationships.  As Robert Pavlis  says on his blog, "Garden Myths".  If it is anecdotal then it is anecdotal - not scientific evidence. 

A major misconception - particularly with scientists is that they are dealing with "facts" rather than reasonable consensus based on current evidence.   At the moment we rely on statistics and significance to indicate relationships although how robust this is, can and should be questioned. 

Social scientists in the 1970s and 1980s started to question whether science was as objective as it made out.  It would seem that a great deal of science seemed to have been noticeably distorted by cultural considerations.  This was not done deliberately but as a result of science being embedded in culture. 

You can see this particularly in gardening myths.  What seems to be a "religious" approach to modern compost making probably originated from the Victorian kitchen gardens of the super rich.  There were no scientifically developed seed and cutting composts so they had to develop these composts for themselves.  Each head gardener would have their own recipe and methods.  However, nowadays we can buy reliable growing media from a garden centre without having to go through what seems to be a religious ceremony to produce the same thing from garden waste.  You don't need anything or to do anything special to produce very passable compost.  Just heap it in a pile and leave it for a year.  Now if this is not questioned then it will carry on as it has for 300 years. 

For example the term, "well rotted manure or well rotted compost" is used by Abercrombe's  in the 18th century through Loudon in the 19th century until the television programs of the 21st century.  No one seems to question what "well rotted" means.  However, Dowding does say use year old, friable manure.  I just wonder if it is a year from when it comes out of the animal or one year from when it was delivered to the garden - or whatever.  What is well rotted manure?  I am not really bothered because I put it on the garden as soon as I get it anyway.  Its not doing any good in a pile. 

Which takes us to the "burning of roots" misconception.  While fresh stable manure quickly heats up in a four or five foot pile,  it doesn't do this in a thin layer on the garden - anecdotally.  However, if the manure is nutrient rich then there may be an increase in the concentration of salts in the soil and water will tend to be drawn out of the root giving the impression of "burning. "  But I have never seen this in all the years I have been heavily manuring the allotment.  Thankfully Dowding seems to agree with this.  The Victorian kitchen gardeners used fresh stable manure packed into 3-4 foot stacks to make hot beds and this might have been where this came from.  Also they had so much manure compared to today that they could leave it to rot down for some time before using it. 

Dowding says a little bit about nitrogen depletion by woody material as well.  The Victorian gardeners did use bark chippings called tan, produced from the tanning industry, to make hot beds.  However, they did not use it on the soil probably because they did not need to.  They had so much manure.  Digging in branches and woody stems would have seemed perverse to the outdoor gardeners because it would make digging that much more difficult.  To keep digging up long woody stems would slow the work down and make it hard. 

There is little solid evidence that woody chippings necessarily produce temporary nitrogen depletion particularly if used as a mulch.  I can't be sure where this misconception has come from but it sure is tenacious. 

One of the findings about misconceptions is how difficult it is  to change them. The attitude; "it doesn't matter whether you are right or wrong, what matters is whether you are sure." can be adopted by the religious and conspiracists but should not be the mantra of  the scientist. 

What irritates me a little is the way people use science to debunk science.  You can't logically do that.  You need to question the evidence.  Dowding does the, " Aha got you."

This is because they do not understand the nature of scientific method.  If older data suggests that there is a lull in global warming then a more recent set of data suggests that this is incorrect, it does not invalidate science.  This is just normal science - as technology improves the resolution of the data also gets better.  Questioning  other people's data is a fundamental process in science.  Scientists are doing it all the time.  They will be very dismissive of other scientists research and challenge them at every turn.  I know because I have been at the receiving end of quite severe dismissive criticism.  However, I would not have it any other way.  I would rather have the criticism than publish research that was not correct. 

This does not mean that science is incorrect just that people are being as rigorous as they can be.  Science research can be a rough and tumble world especially if you are working in a controversial area. However, scientists have powerful methods and big machines that test out theories so if anyone is likely to discover inconsistencies - believe me they will.    A lot of scientists would like to debunk orthodox theories but they need to come up with very secure data to do so.  You have to be right not just sure. 

So the word "proof" and the word "truth"  should not really be applied to science.  I would rather use the word "probably" and, "the weight of evidence suggests at the moment. "  But then I am more of a social scientist than a proper one.