Tuesday, 5 January 2016

Passing on important gardening skills.


I put up a post on Allotment Growers Facebook page indicating my interest in sharing my skills with novice gardeners.

“ I've been thinking about how to help new allotment holders and introduce them to allotmenteering helping them to avoid giving up their allotments after just a few weeks or months because they have become overwhelmed. I was thinking of putting on a workshop/course where we take over an abandoned allotment high in bindweed, nettles, couch, and mare's tail, and believe me we have several of those, and turning it around with the help of prospective allotmenteers. It would give them a realistic idea about the amount of work that is necessary. It will also give them a realistic idea of how much you can do if you work full time and have a family. Do you think that this is a good idea?”

It's not an original idea.  Lots of people have tried to show people what to expect.

http://ealingdean.co.uk/getting-started
But just reading about allotments does not give people a clear idea of what taking on an allotment involves.  Every new person taking on an allotment and then giving it up after just a few weeks at our site, said that they were experienced gardeners and understood how much work was necessary to turn around an untidy allotment. 

 I have had an allotment for about 33 years now and been gardening for over 50 years. Surely in that time I have gathered enough skills to be able to pass them on to younger more novice gardeners without seeming arrogant?

Skills are so important and they are very hard to learn from books.  You have to perfect them over many years.  Most websites say that it takes about 10,000 hours of practising to learn a skill and become proficient in it.  I am interested in passing on skills not on teaching people things they can learn from books. 

So why have we shied right away from teaching skills and concentrated on more academic teaching?

We have people who can name, talk and write about plants but find maintaining a large allotment very difficult.  The number of times that I have read that a particular technique will be easier and not so strenuous are countless.  If you have experienced using your skills in gardening then you realise that there are no short cuts.  Allotmenteering is skilled hard work. 

I don’t know if it is the only reason, but for gardening it may be the main one, the fear of being held responsible for any injury that a student suffers.  When you are dealing with machinery, sharp tools, knives, secateurs and putting your hands into compost and manure, I can see that there might be a problem.  But why?

Is it because people will not take responsibility for their own safety?  I worked for some time teaching outdoor education and all the activities had to be assessed for safety - what some call risk assessments.  I also had to have an up to date first aid certificate.  Safety instructions were given at the beginning of all activities.  But really it was just about using your intelligence to keep yourself out of danger.  It is the Darwin effect – anyone stupid enough to injure themselves should be removed from the gene pool anyway and not infect the rest of us with genes that lead you to act so recklessly that you kill yourself. 

When I took the RHS practical gardening certificates, one of the main elements was risk assessment and personal protection equipment. 

But do I really want to get into this stifling, quagmire of teaching other people how to remain safe? And what happens if they do injure themselves? 

So am I going to persevere with the workshop idea?  I have no idea what hazards an overgrown allotment may hide.  Broken glass, sharp nails, rusty knives, hidden tools, holes and large boulders are only some that I have come across.  The one that I have to put up with at the moment is urine filled bottles thrown over the hedge from the road that runs alongside the allotment site. 

So I doubt that old blokes, like me, that have spent more than 10000 hours perfecting skills will not be rushing to share their knowledge.  The perception of old people as useless will be further perpetuated and skills will be lost.   

 Sad world.

Monday, 4 January 2016

Another reason for not having raised beds?


Way back in the 1970s, when I was teaching, there was a movement to use school grounds as a learning environment rather than just a green desert of Italian rye grass. 

One of the school grounds ideas was to develop a scented garden with herbs and other interesting smelly plants.  Another idea was to make a disabled garden where children with disabilities could garden with impunity.

I had plans for a scented garden to have a sunken path through it so that the children could be at nose level with the plants.  The disabled garden would have raised beds, have scented and tactile plants which were accessible to children who had limited mobility and sight.   Many schools took on these kinds of projects and lots of them have raised beds from the 1980s just for those reasons.

There were no boxed raised bed systems on allotments that I remember.  Some allotments had wooden edging but mainly it was edging plants like box, lavender and rosemary; if anything at all. 

During the Victorian era and earlier the British walled kitchen gardens were dug with beds where soil from paths or alleyways were thrown up and levelled out.  In addition, large areas of the garden were used to make hot beds which were raised mounds of fresh horse manure.  Both the raised beds with alleys and raised hot beds did not have boards to keep the soil in place. 

The best modern example of this is the methods recorded on http://www.alan-chadwick.org/html%20pages/techniques.html
The American tradition of raised beds seems to have originated from Alan Chadwick’s writings.  The beds were about four feet across and allowed access from both sides.  About the same time as Alan Chadwick was lecturing in the United States Bill Mollison was developing similar ideas in Australia.  Neither advocated boxing these in with wood though. Charles Dowding, an advocate of no dig, says that he is not boxing his beds in any more. 

The French gardeners took hot bed gardening to new levels around Paris during the late 1800s and their methods were brought to Britain by C.D. McKay in his book “The French Garden in England”.  However, they did not use boards to keep the manure from falling into the alleyways.  If you read Abercrombie or Loudon carefully they say use boards to start the hot bed pile but remove them afterwards. 

So there was a tradition of four foot wide “raised” beds with alleys between them way back into the past.  Edging was traditionally a plant rather than wood and these were placed around the quarters rather than the individual beds. 

After the dissolution of the railways, railway sleepers became very easy to acquire and were relatively cheap.  Some people used these to make raised beds to plant rhododendrons, camellias and magnolias after filling them with peat. 

So I think that the wooden raised bed developed from the use of sleepers in flower gardens and the decorative bricks used in retaining walls and raised beds of disabled gardens. 

Furthermore flower garden designers were using more and more wooden containers for patio gardens during the 1980s and these could have just got a little bigger and used for vegetables. 

Now there are many reasons for and against making boxed raised beds but one that has just been brought to my attention is the problem of using treated wood.  Railway sleepers cannot be used in the garden anymore and if you are using them then you should seriously consider taking them out. 

Whereas I am very sceptical of just accepting what it says on websites, they do generate a lot of thought. 


This is one such website. 

Now if you have read any other of my blog musings, you will know that I am not a fan of boxed in raised beds.  However, I never thought of the problem of treated wood being used.  I know that lots of people are using decking off cuts to make their raised beds and this wood will have been treated in some way or other to prevent rotting.  I thought that tanalised wood was made using tannin from oak bark but I was clearly wrong. 

So, I have just bought several tanalised tree stakes to train my espaliered apple and pear trees.  Are they safe to use in the garden?   I’m not at all sure now. 

The debate on Grow Your Own website clearly says that tanalised wood is safe:


Yet I always ask myself why I am growing my own food.  Is it to produce food that is man made chemical free?  If it is why use pesticides?  All that tanalisation is is applying fungicide to garden wood.  I would rather not use wood at all if I could get away with it. Cuz wood rots.  Where I have to, such as the shed, I like to keep it off the soil as much as possible.  My shed is on concrete slabs but how much that will do to keep my allotment safe from tanalising chemicals I don’t know.   

I am trying to make my allotment a little more fungi friendly for at least two reasons.  Firstly I would like to encourage mychorrhizal associations that  benefit most allotment plants.  Secondly, you can eat the fruiting spore producing caps of fungi.   I just need to learn to identify more edible ones. 

Using a lot more woody shredded material as a mulch on the allotment means that I would like to encourage fungi to rot down the mulch during the year and then it can be dug in during the winter months and be replenished with new material in the spring. 

When encouraging wildlife onto the allotment we should not forget the vast fungi kingdom. 

The chemicals in tantalised wood might not do humans any harm at all but they will certainly damage the fungi living in the allotment soil.  What effect they have on other soil life is anyone's guess. 
Now what on earth do I do about the tree stakes?

Sunday, 3 January 2016

Sowing Seeds onions, leeks and tomatoes

It is a fault of mine that when I read that other gardeners are starting to sow seeds, I immediately think that I am far behind and need to get myself organised to sow as many seeds as possible.  Well I am going to make sure that I am happy with the growing conditions before I do anything.  I am becoming an advocate of slow and measured gardening.

It has been unseasonably warm right up to Christmas and now it is very tempting to sow some onions, leeks and tomatoes.  I do have some general purpose commercial compost and might wander down to the allotment and sow these seeds in some small 3 inch pots.  I will bring them home and put them in the airing cupboard to germinate.  They will have to be checked every day to make sure that they do not get drawn up.  It is called etiolation in the posh gardening books. 

I sowed onion Bedfordshire Champion, leek Blue Solaise and tomato Alicante. I have left the onions and leeks in the greenhouse on the allotment but I have bought the tomatoes home. 

I think that I am going to write in the blog when I am going to sow seeds.  I always label the seeds with their name and when I sowed them.  However, once the plants are transplanted into the allotment soil, I wash the labels and store them away without taking any more notice of what I wrote on them.  This means that I don't know when I  sowed seeds in the past.  I just have a general idea.  Now, I have been sowing seeds for about 50 odd years, and I know more or less when the best sowing time is for probably all the veg I am likely to grow.  However, with a better record I might be surprised by something.  I hope so because this is what makes gardening interesting. 

It has been raining for about three days now, off and on.  The ground is completely unsuitable for any kind of gardening so I will keep off the soil until it has dried out completely. I don't have much to do on the allotment at the moment except to put more supports up for the blackberry and loganberry.  I am going to move some supports that I put up for the autumn raspberries and use them for espaliering the new apples that I planted.  If I don't put up supports for the espaliers, I tend to step on them and break the graft at the union.  I've done that three times now!! That is really a priority because I like to train the lateral stems as soon as they are big enough and it keeps my big feet away from the plants. 

The rain means that I am not going to plant any garlic, onion sets or elephant garlic until the ground is a lot drier.  Lots of people have put theirs in during the autumn and winter.  I don't think that it matters one iota when they go in.  Mine will catch up and be caught up by alliums planted later in the season. 

I have been given some large pieces of cardboard.  These will be used as weed suppressers around the allotment.  They can be laid flat overlapping themselves and then covered with a good layer of shredded prunings.  I am also going to add the smaller pieces to the compost bins because cardboard seems to rot down remarkably quickly.  Most books and internet sites suggest that you take off any plastic based sticky tape holding them together.  I don't bother because it falls out of the compost really quickly once the cardboard has started to rot away well. 

All kinds of plastic, metal and glass fall out of the compost as it is rotting and being turned.  I try not to leave any of this in the compost and have a plastic bag handily tied to the compost pallets to gather up the unwanted elements of the compost.  I do not tolerate any broken glass on the allotment and it is removed immediately no mater what else I am doing.  The last thing I want on the allotment is a bad cut especially with the amount of manure I add to the soil. 

So I have several large piles of well rotted compost in strategic areas of the allotment and I was going to drag these across the surface of the beds after digging in the green manure. 

Should I use some of this to sow seed into? 

In the olden days before there was much "seed compost" sold in the garden centres - indeed before there were any garden centres, I used to sow seeds in ordinary garden soil.  My germination rate might not have been quite as good as it is with sterile growing medium but I still had my successes.  I have got into this mind set that if I use home made compost or garden soil, I will get very poor germination due to fungi diseases.  It is just what the commercial guys want you to believe and the way that they make their money. 

However, it would be a lot cheaper with the number of seeds that I sow each year to use my own home made compost.  I think that an experiment is going to have to be done.  There are several problems with home made compost.  Usually the commercial bods put a wetting agent into the compost to make sure that it remains damp for the longest time.  Using my own might mean I'll have to water the seedlings quite often.  Secondly, the compost can form a cap which is reluctant to allow water to penetrate into the compost.  I am wondering if adding horticultural grit or sand to the compost would help to prevent this problem. 

Now I think that I will wander up to the allotment, leave the cardboard by the compost bins and sow a few seeds.  Maybe I will even transplant some more sweet peas.  I have about 200 plants now in three inch pots all pinched out and growing their side shoots.  Do I need any more sweet peas I ask myself. I must still have at least that many growing in the large pots and needing to be transplanted.  I am loath to throw them away.

Sunday, 27 December 2015

Ken Thompson's "Sceptical Gardener" and permaculture


I have just been reading one of my Christmas presents, Ken Thompson's Sceptical Gardener.  I am prepared to forgive him for writing for the Telegraph but his dismissal of permaculture is a little perfunctory.   While understanding his conservative audience, maybe a little more circumspect research would have given him a few more insights. 

He makes much of looking at several websites.  I realise that today’s students are encouraged to use the internet as a useful tool.  However, I always taught that going to the original peer reviewed published research was a much better way of exploring ideas. 

While Bill Mollison’s book “Permaculture a Designer’s Manual” is a little out of date being published in 1988, it is still a research tool of choice when considering permaculture.  The web sites are eclectic and reflect permaculture's inclusiveness.  It is not necessary to agree with most views on these sites because they are just individual interpretations of the basic principles in the Manual. 

Ken Thompson seems to equate permaculture with forest gardening and then dismiss it because it is not a valid method of producing enough food to feed the world.  Totally agree that forest gardening is not a panacea for all the world’s problems; however it is not a significant part of permaculture.  I would suggest, however, that good design of new forests would produce a lot more resources than the monocultures do at present. 

Although there is little mention of forest gardening in, “Permaculture a Designer’s Manual” it is easily integrated into the framework as are other methods and philosophies.  The experimental works of Martin Crawford and Patrick Whitefield have indicated that productive forest trees can be designed into a landscape in order to produce useful crops.  However, this is just one, and the most remote, of five areas or zones that permaculture designs make productive for human food and materials sustainability. 

Unfortunately for someone that wants to take permaculture seriously, it does seem to have been hijacked by the more extreme members of the environmental movements.  Biodynamics, lunar gardening, new wave philosophy together with American survivalists all seems to include permaculture type concepts in their literature.  However, these ideas are not permaculture and neither is forest gardening. 

So what is permaculture?  It is an overarching landscape design procedure.  It takes the fundamental factors of living systems and designs them to achieve the most productive and sustainable and abundant outcomes that a particular landscape and its topography can provide.  It seeks to control elements like water and nutrient availability through low appropriate technology.  It is pragmatic in the extreme.  It celebrates what works.  It is based on a careful consideration of landscape potential together with intense observation. 

No matter where it has been tried throughout the world – Australia, Ethiopia, China, Jordan, Morocco, United States, Britain – it seems to be an effective way of producing a very sustainable, low fossil carbon method of agriculture and horticulture. 

It is a method of mitigating the effects of environmental extremes like flooding and drought and turning what seems to be impossible growing environments to advantage.  It seems to work both at the macro and micro level.  I have adopted many of the principles of permaculture in the small landscape of my allotment and, although it is still early days, it would seem to be achieving what I want it to do.  I don't have a slug problem but I certainly have a lack of ducks problem. 

My permaculture design certificate.
Although I was very sceptical, like Ken Thompson, I decided to take the permaculture design course just to have a more in depth understanding of its principles.  The more I learnt and the more I watched the video evidence the less sceptical I became. 

Permaculture reminds landscape designers to consider climate, aspect, water, nutrients, dwellings, access, energy production, recycling, productive fauna and flora, and materials such as clay and gravel.  It melds all these elements into a synergetic system which is designed to meet the reasonable needs of people. 

So it’s a little more than planting nut trees Ken Thompson.    

Wednesday, 23 December 2015

Christmas vegetables.

I went up to the allotment today to get the Christmas day vegetables.  Actually, they will probably last us into the new year. These are the vegetables I got either out of the ground or from the store shed.  I had to get them today because it will take me all tomorrow to prepare them.  That and wrapping presents. 
Vegetables for Christmas.

So we have some kale, Brussel sprouts, swede, red cabbage, leeks, celery, celeriac, pumpkin, squash, shallot, garlic, elephant garlic, oca, carrots, onions and parsnips.  Some of them are a bit moth eaten but that does not alter the taste.  I might get some beans and peas out of the freezer too. 

Happy Christmas and a very good, fruitful year.